We counted. We did not test.
Anvil & Blade does not run a test workshop. Every ranking on this site comes from counting what working smiths and knife makers recommend, then checking the specs against the maker's own listing.
The method
Collect
We gather forum threads where smiths ask what to buy. [SOURCE LIST]
Count
We tally every model recommended or warned against, and the reason given.
Check
We confirm weight, material and price against the maker's own listing.
Rank
Picks are ordered by the count, then re-checked every [N] months.
What we do not do
No hands-on testsWe say so on every page instead of implying otherwise.
No star ratingsA score we made up would tell you nothing.
No paid placementA maker cannot buy a position in a ranking.
How the site earns
Some links go to retailers that pay us a commission when you buy. It costs you nothing extra and does not change the count. Full affiliate disclosure